Godfather’s Pizza

Reviews

• Megan V.

  star star star star_border star_border 10 October 2026

  The 12 year old in me wants to say "GODFATHERS IS THE ULTIMATE BEST PIZZA EVER!"...but sadly that was a long time ago and my tastes have evolved since then.
  
  For a small town pizza joint, Godfathers was always my go-to in town. I don't know if it was the weekly Pizza Days in elementary school that brainwashed me or what, but stopping in here is a hard habit to break.
  
  I went by last week since I was in town and got a fresh-out-of-the-oven slice. I gotta ask you Mr. Godfather, where's the taste!? I think I may have outgrown you :*(
  
  There's only a few options for pizza in Delhi, this place is fairly expensive for the amount and quality you get.
  
  I'll always love you, and you're fun to have around for a quick nibble, but I'm glad I have more options to choose from when I want some real adult pizza-time.

• Tina H.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 10 October 2026

  The pizzas are very small! If you are expecting a "medium" size, then you should order a "large", the sizing seems to be off by one size. The vegetarian had onions, green peppers, olives, and canned mushrooms (blech!). No tomatoes on a vegetarian!?!? It was not very appealing in look, and taste wasn't terrible, but definitely not impressive either. Normally we would order from the Pizza House - but, they were closed, so we gave Godfathers a try.
  
  The service was friendly, but they seemed confused during the ordering process. They forgot about one of the pizzas we ordered - so there was a slight delay.